Transcript
music
Gentle, trilling music with a steady drumbeat plays under the dialogue.
promo
Speaker: Bullseye with Jesse Thorn is a production of MaximumFun.org and is distributed by NPR. [Music fades out.]
music
“Huddle Formation” from the album Thunder, Lightning, Strike by The Go! Team. A fast, upbeat, peppy song. Music plays as Jesse speaks, then fades out.
jesse thorn
It’s Bullseye. I’m Jesse Thorn. Kate Berlant and John Early are comedians and performers. Kate has appeared in movies like Sorry to Bother You and Once Upon a Time in Hollywood. John has appeared on TV shows like Search Party, 30 Rock, and The Afterparty. They’ve also been best friends and collaborators for over a decade. They’ve done sketches on YouTube and other platforms, live performances on TV and around the country. When John and Kate perform onstage together, it’s really something. There is a frenetic, unhinged energy. They tend to veer between intense platonic love and seething contempt thinly masked with backhanded compliments and probing questions. Their TV sketches are equally unhinged—though, in a slightly different way. The settings are usually pretty grounded. The stakes aren’t too high. But they almost always insert a little bit of surreality into the mundane: a meet cute at a farmers’ market where both Kate and John have enormous face tattoos. An awkward “who gets the check” moment where you pay the bill with hot, melted caramel sauce. Their newest project combines both of those practices into one very, very funny special. It’s called Would It Kill You to Laugh, and it comes out this week on Peacock. Here’s the premise. John Early and Kate Berlant play fictionalized versions of themselves. Decades ago, the two starred on a smash hit sitcom, called He’s Gay, She’s Half-Jewish. Shortly after the show wrapped, they had a very public falling out. Between the sketches in Would It Kill You to Laugh, Kate and John reunite for an interview with journalist Meredith Viera, and it becomes very clear that—while it's been a while—the old wounds aren’t quite healed.
sound effect
Music swells and fades.
clip
Kate (Would It Kill You to Laugh): I needed this. I think I’m actually now really looking around— Meredith: Cathartic. Yeah, yeah. Kate: It’s really cathartic. John: Yeah. [Sighs.] Kate: I’m getting a little dizzy. Meredith: Oh, jeez. Kate: I’m fine. John: Okay. Okay. Kate: I’m gonna move through it. But I’m getting a little dizzy. Meredith: And for you, John? Same feelings? John: Uuuh. Uum. Meredith: I’m sorry. John: [Voice pinched.] I feel really good. Kate: We can’t hear you, sweetie. John: [Strangled.] I feel good. Kate: You look—I’m looking at you. It’s so strange, ‘cause you look 12, but you also look 60. And it’s—I love the way your—the shading and you finally found a foundation that matches. John: You know, it’s so funny. Obviously, I haven’t seen you in years. [Chuckles.] Kate: Yeah, yeah. I know. Years! Years! Yeah, years! John: Um, you know, I haven’t seen you in person. [Beat.] Um. I haven’t seen you in person, but I also haven’t seen you just kind of reflected anywhere in the culture. So, what have—what have you been up to? Kate: I’ve been really good. I’ve been busy. I’ve been in New York doing theatre. Which is— John: AWWWWW!
sound effect
Music swells and fades.
jesse
[They laugh.] John Early, Kate Berlant, thanks for coming on Bullseye.
kate berlant
Thanks for having us!
john early
Thank you for having us.
jesse
Congratulations on the special; it’s so funny. I like that clip, really. I did not pick that clip. But it really illustrates some real hallmarks of the Berlant-Early relationship, including insulting funny voice, false illness. [They laugh and John agrees.] Like, there’s a real laundry list of stuff you seem to enjoy doing together. [They agree.] What was the—what was like the first thing that you discovered yourselves doing together that you were like, “This is what I enjoy in my life?”
john
That’s a great question. [Kate agrees.] I mean, I think it would be this exact energy from the clip. Like, when we first became friends, we watched a—I showed Kate, if I may take credit.
kate
You may! You may.
john
Like, you know. You know, as you do in early friendships—early on in friendships in our modern era. You show each other YouTube videos. And I showed Kate this video of Suzanne Somers and—
crosstalk
John & Kate: Joyce DeWitt.
john
Reuniting after like maybe 30 years of not speaking to each other and having a very public falling out. And—
kate
On Three’s Company.
john
On Three’s Company, yep. And it was like Suzanne Somers own kind of YouTube series, called Café Mom. And so, it was like—she was in full control over it, like in control of like the lighting. It was very much her.
jesse
Was it like a professionally produced situation? [They confirm.]
john
She had some sort of talk show on YouTube and used that as a platform to have this reuniting.
kate
To invite Joyce on.
john
Yeah. And we just—there was just something in that dynamic that I think really spoke to the overlap in our sensibility—sensibilities, plural. And I don’t know, I think we just—that video kind of ignited a certain kind of like tense kind of smiley, kind of undercut-y like thing.
kate
Yeah. And they were—in that clip, it’s pretty amazing. They’re both really trying to—it’s this subtle competition over who is kindest and who is the most—who’s moved on. [John and Jesse.] It’s the past. You know. But they’re like—
john
[Saccharinely.] “Yeeeah.”
kate
Yeah, and it’s wacky. [Laughs.]
john
It’s wackadoo. And it’s very layered. It’s very, very layered.
kate
Yeah, and I think John and I—that’s kind of the first—the thing that brought us together… is and remains that kind of obsession of those layered moments in social nicety. [John agrees.] And the subtext that we refuse to acknowledge. [John laughs.]
jesse
I do sometimes worry, watching your work together. I think it’s so funny, and sometimes I worry that you know that so well that you might be bad people. Like, I don’t like think that, but I— [They affirm.] It gives me that concern. [They agree.]
kate
Everyone always is so shocked by how sweet I am. [Jesse laughs.]
john
I know.
kate
You’re meeting me right now, Jesse. I need a tuna melt; I’m a little hungry. I should’ve had the tuna melt before the interview. [They agree.]
john
Yeah, it’s good for that for that fuel.
kate
But I have the tuna melt kind of in this—in the near future. And I’m gonna—even now, you feel the energy lifting, just talking about the tuna melt.
john
Yeah, yeah, talking about the tuna melt.
kate
I’m very meal-oriented in that way. So, just knowing the tuna melt is near, I will let the energy bubble to the surface.
john
And I brought pastries for all the kind of technicians today, and their kids.
kate
[Pleasantly.] And that’s a lie!
john
That’s a lie. [Jesse laughs.] Very sweet. No, we’re not bad people, but I do think we have—I do think we enjoy the kind of freedom of playing bad people. You know? [Kate agrees.] Like, there’s something very—
kate
‘Cause we’re not rude. We don’t have the bravery to be rude.
john
No, exactly, exactly! There’s something very liberating about being just openly rude.
jesse
[Laughing.] What—what was the first show that the two of you did together?
john
Live show? [Jesse confirms.] We did a—
crosstalk
John & Kate: Union Hall.
kate
Sold it out.
john
Sold it out.
kate
It’s like 40 seats. [They laugh.] It’s more. But yeah, we sold it out. That’s not what I meant to repeat. [Laughs.] We, you know, did a show at Union Hall where it began with a wedding—or began with us getting married. And actually, I had a bouquet of kale.
john
She literally walked down the aisle with a bouquet of kale. It started with me onstage in a suit, and like I—
kate
Like straight guy.
john
Yeah, straight guy like trying not to cry. And then, yeah. Kate came down in a wedding dress and a bouquet of kale, and we did like 33 like insane sketches, and it was like probably—it was like a very bloated kind of like two-hour show. [Laughs.] [Kate agrees.] But it was so—it was so exciting.
jesse
What was exciting about it?
john
Well, honestly, it was exciting—frankly—that it was sold out. Like, I think that Kate and I like—you know, we had a very—I mean, literally, day one of our friendship, we were very—verbalized that we knew we would be working together, that it was like a very—it was like—and not just like, “Let’s collaborate.” It was like, “Oh, this is a partnership.”
kate
This is huge. Yeah. Yeah.
john
[Laughing.] Yeah, this is huge is a common refrain.
jesse
Where were you? What was the—what was the context for it? Where were you?
kate
We were on the set of a friend’s short film, and it was—there was like a room where the snacks were. And John and I started talking, and I was like instantly upset whenever somebody else would come in the room and we had to pivot the conversation to them and become sociable. And I’d be like, “Okay! You got your snack! Get out!” [John laughs.] And I really felt like I just wanted to talk to John. And we were just screaming laughing all day. And then we parted at like midnight at Grand Central Station. Why were we at Grand Central? We were. We were transferring.
john
Because we were shooting near there. Yeah.
kate
To the six.
john
To the six. Oh, and On the 6—J-Lo’s album, also.
kate
And it was midnight, and we were parting. And then we texted. I got back to my apartment, and we texted until like four AM. And I remember John was like, “If I don’t see you in two days, I’ll kill myself.”
john
I think I said, “I’ll kill myself in public.” [Chuckles.]
kate
Oh, yeah, yeah. And then we just—
john
And then, I remember Kate—I mean, not to brag, but you were like, “I’m watching your YouTube videos and I’m breathless.” [Jesse cackles.]
kate
Oh my god, did I say that? [Laughs.]
john
You said “breathless”. I was like [makes a strangled, excited sound]. It was really—it was very romantic. [Kate agrees.]
jesse
Is there a sketch that you did in that first stage show at Union Hall that you’re still proud of?
kate
No recollection, basically.
john
We kissed—remember? We kissed.
kate
Oh yeah! Wait, we did?!
john
Which we’ve like never done since.
kate
Woah.
john
I guess we did in the Bieber sketch that didn’t make it. But we—the—we kissed. Remember? I played your mother.
kate
Oh! This is—wait, this is amazing. And we should actually shoot that for real.
john
We should definitely do this. Kate played my daughter. And she was like—were you reading?
kate
No, I was brushing my hair in a vanity mirror—pretending to brush my hair before bed.
john
Yeah, and I was her like—you know, a severe kind of period mother character.
kate
Like, pacing behind me and being like—
john
“You [censored].”
kate
Yeah, like calling me a [censored]. And I was like, “Please, mother!” And like brushing my hair. And then you grabbed me and kissed me.
john
Yeah. Like, grabbed her by the face. And you were putting on lipstick, and we like—
kate
You—and then you grabbed me—yeah. It’s pretty amazing.
john
Yeah. And it was like—it was unwritten, I would say. [Kate agrees with a laugh.] It was just like wild improvised genre parody. We should do it.
kate
Doing that—doing like a Vermeer, like making it really—
john
Yes, fully period. [Kate confirms.] M’kay. Well.
kate
Great. See you in season two.
john
And we’ll credit you, Jesse!
jesse
Thank you. I would prefer executive producer, but I’ll take co-executive producer if it comes to it. [They agree playfully.] Josh Lindgren is my agent. You can just give him a call. CAA. [Chuckles.] So, the two of you have been working together ever since. And being a comedy duo isn’t the most—
john
Chic. [They chuckle.]
jesse
Yeah, it’s not like the most—the easiest or most—
john
It’s outre.
jesse
Yeah, remunerative lane. You know what I mean? Like, there’s just not—I mean, as with sketch comedy, like there’s only so many places you can do that. [John agrees.] And it’s twice as expensive as doing something by yourself. You know? Like, going on tour or something like that.
kate
Unless you share a hotel bed, like we do.
john
Yes, exactly.
jesse
Aw, that’s really sweet.
john
On our—when we tour, we share a bed.
jesse
They have hotel rooms with two beds in them.
kate
We’ve gotten those too. But why? You know. [They laugh.] We’ve had to beds, yeah.
john
No, we have had two beds, but rarely.
kate
But sometimes it’s one! Yeah. [They laugh.]
john
Yeah, no, honestly, we—I’ve always been very like—the duo, the comedy duo I think is—there’s something very kind of sweet and old school about it. And that’s also very sad that that’s old school. And I think that’s only old school a result of like—
kate
Rugged individualism?
john
It’s—yeah! It’s literally—it’s the way rugged individualism has now like kind of manifested through social media. You know? I don’t think there’s any sort of actual public like change like in like desire. [Kate echoes the word.] I don’t think the public’s like, “Down with duos! Like, we want individuals now.” I just think it’s that social media has become so prevalent, obviously. Everyone has their little platform, and for some reason—I mean, it’s very clear why. They want us all atomized and alienated, so we can—you know.
kate
Rip each other to shreds. Yeah.
john
[Chuckling.] Yeah, exactly, so that we can’t—you know—come together and overthrow the ruling class. But like I do think there’s something bizarre about the fact that—imagine if Kate and I had a shared Instagram. That would be corny. Why, though? [Kate agrees several times.] Because honestly, it would be crass, because it would be like we were trying to kind of like sell and market our duo-ship. But anyway, while we were shooting this special—because it’s been a long time since Kate and I have been given the opportunity to make something on a big platform, while we were shooting it, there were times when I would be like [laughing] so moved. Where I would be like, “Kate, I like—I really believe in the duo. Like, this is so special. Like, this is so important right now.” Everyone is like screaming on their phones—you know. And I understand why they’re screaming. I get it! You know, but it’s like—it’s really—I think it’s—there is something profound right now, about like insisting on something that isn’t maybe as clearly—that doesn’t snugly fit in with what’s seen as marketable. Like, we love being a duo. We love having long sketches that can breathe and where like things can happen subtextually, where they’re not spelled out. You know, like I think that’s… I think it’s important to insist on that, even as the venues for that keep like shrinking and dying.
jesse
More of my interview with John Early and Kate Berlant after a quick break. Stay with us. It’s Bullseye, from MaximumFun.org and NPR.
music
Relaxed synth with a steady beat.
jesse
It’s Bullseye. I’m Jesse Thorn. If you’re just joining us, I am talking with the comedians Kate Berlant and John Early. Kate is a standup comic and actor who has appeared in Tuca & Birdie, Space Force, and more. John is an actor who’s had roles on Search Party and Los Espookys. The two have been working together as a comedy duo for over a decade, and they are very good at it. They have a brand-new special that debuts this week on Peacock, called Would It Kill You to Laugh. Let’s get back into our conversation. Let’s play a little bit from my guests—Kate Berlant and John Early’s—new special, which is called Would It Kill You to Laugh. And this is the two of them in a book club. They have not read the book, ‘cause they heard it’s a pretty chill book club. It turns out to be a pretty not chill book club. And so, they are—they are trying to play along.
sound effect
Music swells and fades.
clip
Kate: Loved it. Completely. Loved it completely! John: Loved it. Loved it in a way where I’m just like, “I loved it. Period.” Speaker 1: What did you love about it, Kate? Kate: You know what? You know what? You know what? You know what? I think that people who look like me have had the stage for so long. The microphone for so long. Right? I just kind of feel like as a way to rectify like the sins of my ancestors—by the way, I hate you guys! I reeeally do! Um. I’m gonna give the floor to someone else. Speaker 1: Uh, John do you have any thoughts that you wanna share? I mean, any impressions you have are welcome here. John: Well, I’m gay. [Beat.] I’m gay. And I just wanna get right out in front of that. You know? ‘Cause I have to wake up to that every morning. It’s not just a hat that I can take off. Speaker 2: What did you think of the book? John: Where were you guys when you finished it? I’ll start. Um, I remember being in my bedroom and getting to the end and going [sighs exaggeratedly].
sound effect
Music swells and fades.
kate
[They laugh.] So fun to hear it chopped up and—
john
Chopped and screwed.
kate
In the ears. Yeah.
jesse
The two of you often seem to be having a contest when you’re doing a sketch. [They agree.] Like, a lot of sketches have a straight character, joke character. The two of you seem to do a lot of goading-related sketches.
john
Yes. What does goading mean, if I were a person who didn’t know?
jesse
Like, poking each other. Like, trying to escalate. [They agree.]
kate
We slip into competition energy very quickly.
john
Yeah. But what I like about book club is like we are kind of—we are on the same time.
kate
We’re a united front. We both didn’t read it. Yeah. [They laugh.] Yeah.
john
Yeah. And I think we—that was why we did that sketch. We were like, “What’s something where we’re not kind of like—"
kate
At each other’s throats. Yeah. [They laugh.]
jesse
You also have a lot of comedy where you name your identity categories. [They confirm.] That—I mean, like when it comes to things that might be seen as Millennial in their nature, I think struggling with trying to figure out how to relate to your identity category is—or categories—is one of them.
john
Absolutely. How to exploit it. Hyphenize it.
jesse
I’ve probably seen—
john
Profit off of it.
jesse
—eight bits where, John, you’ve announced that you’re gay. [Laughs.]
john
It’s my—it’s the oldest trick in the—one time, my mom was like, “You say you’re gay a lot.” [They chuckle.] I was like yeeeah.
kate
Well, it’s one of the funniest things you do just in conversation. Or like, with just like—I don’t even— [John agrees.] Like, we’ll be at a restaurant, and John will be like, “Sorry. I’m gay.” And then order something. You’ll like go back on your order and blame it—
john
And blame it on my homosexuality.
kate
Blame the moment on the fact that you’re gay. [They chuckle.] It’s so funny.
jesse
What do those identity categories actually, practically mean to you, do you think?
crosstalk
Kate: It’s my culture. John: Nothing. [Laughs.] Kate: Yeah, it’s everything. [Laughs.]
kate
Yeah, I mean, we have another joke in the special that we’re on a sitcom called He’s Gay, She’s Half-Jewish. Which is another sort of… the joke of my proclaiming being half-Jewish. [Chuckles.] And what that could possibly mean. Even though, you know, actually I’d be fully Jewish. Anyway, it’s a long—it’s a long story. We won’t get into it.
john
We won’t get into that. We don’t—yeah.
kate
But what do they actually mean? Well, I think as John said before, just these categories that can become—you know—weaponized or kind of used as some kind of ammo to—or used in some way to be perceived as smart or having something to say. [John agrees.] Or some angle, some experience, and kind of you’re hyperaware of your own experience next to other people’s.
john
Yeah, as if there’s some sort of—right.
kate
And being very hyperconscious about—you know—saying the right thing and…
john
As if there’s a monolithic experience for any identity group. [Kate agrees.] Yeah. It’s—I think it—yeah. I think that is just so—I mean, that is not something we even really planned on doing in this special. [Kate confirms.] We—like, the book club sketch is one of the more improvised sketches. And He’s Gay, She’s Half-Jewish just like flew out of Kate’s mouth.
kate
It was like a stupid joke.
john
Yeah. And we were like, “What should the sitcom be called?” [Chuckles.] You know? I think it was like “He’s Gay, She’s Jewish”. And then later, we changed it to half-Jewish.
kate
Which is funnier. Yeah. But—
john
But yeah. So, we don’t—we come by these—or we came by this particular theme, I think, unintentionally. But I do think we are clearly on some level absorbing it from the zeitgeist. There’s a—that’s really in the air. You know? And then—
kate
Yeah, yeah. The need to identify yourself clearly so you can be more directly advertised to. [John giggles and agrees.]
jesse
I remember very vividly an instance in college where I was sitting in the dining hall with my two best buds, who were the co-hosts of this show at the time. And we were sitting with this girl named Rebecca, who I really liked and admired. Really cool, smart lady. And she said, “It’s really hard to sit with you guys.” And I said, “Why’s that, Rebecca?” And like, “’Cause you’re the greatest! Why—?” And she said, “I can’t tell if you’re joking or when you’re joking.”
john
Mm. We get that. For sure.
kate
I struggle with that, because I’m so serious. [They chuckle.] But you know, yeah.
jesse
But you so comfortably slip into your either dumb or insincere or passive aggressive characters in casual conversation. [John agrees.]
kate
No, you’re totally correct. Yeah. I can—I can take it.
john
Or yeah, when we slip into those things, they’re not—it’s often very small. And like we had trouble with our editor, Sophie—one of our editors on this. She was like, “You guys are always—” She was like—we would just, you know—
kate
Be talking?
john
Or we’d have jokes. We’d do like what—to us, what felt like very clear jokes. [Kate affirms.] Just like stuff like—you know, just like, “Hey, Sophie, like do you—” Like, we were editing at my house—you know, and it was just stuff like, “Do you—if you don’t mind not using the bathroom.” You know, stuff like that. Like—and she would just be like, “Oh! I’m sorry!” And you’re like, “Oh no! No! Use the bathroom!” [Kate agrees with a laugh.] So, that does happen a lot, I think. And we’re sorry for it, ‘cause we really don’t mean to.
jesse
The special is really intensely aesthetic. [Kate “ooh”s.] In a way that comedy isn’t often, on video. You know, like usually on film, comedy is just in the middle, and you just catch the funny things that people say or the funny faces they make or whatever. That must have been—I saw that your director also had a cowriting credit on the show. Did you like work on the visual aspects as you were writing? Like, were you trying to think of them as one thing?
john
I—always. [Kate agrees.] I mean, I think we’re always—like, part of the joke is always the kind of genre or the tone or the look of it. I think we’re—Kate, Andy, and I—are all very aesthetically driven. And you know, we certainly don’t wanna do it—we’re never trying to make things, you know, like aesthetically like oppressive.
kate
I know we sort of like—we’re very sensitive to that. We want things to be beautiful and lush and exciting, but also the most important thing to us is that it’s funny. [John agrees.] And we don’t wanna—you know.
john
We don’t wanna take away from that.
kate
And be like, “Well, we have a lens flare. So.” [They chuckle.] “Good luck criticizing this!” Yeah. [John cackles.]
jesse
The special is directed by JJ Abrams. You should explain.
kate
Our director is Andrew DeYoung. So, yes.
jesse
There is a really wonderful “who’s gonna pay the bill” sketch in which you are both—I presume—straight dudes. Kate, you have a soul patch. [She affirms.]
john
It’s unbelievable. Real hair, right?
kate
I don’t know.
john
I think she laid real hair on your chin. It was all so fast.
kate
It was very fast.
jesse
Like, uh, did it come on—you know, like a nylon—like a piece—like a false moustache? Or is it—
kate
It’s like a little piece that she—I don’t even know! Yeah.
john
Yeah, like a—yeah. A little lace front. Glued.
jesse
It’s just on skin? [They confirm.] Like someone who’s had a portion of their head flayed?
kate
Possibly.
john
Possibly, yeah. A cadaver. [Chuckles.]
kate
I don’t know where the hair comes from. I just sign for it when they deliver it.
jesse
What are the things that you think are interesting about straight dudeness? And I can take it. [Kate chuckles.]
john
Oh yeah, well.
kate
We love our boys.
john
We love our straight men. Yes. I think—
jesse
Thank you. That sounded insincere, but I’ll take it.
john
It’s totally real. It’s totally sincere. Truly. I love a straight guy.
kate
We do! I think just like straight male friendship is fascinating to us. Or to me, ‘cause it’s like I have these intense, emotional, involved friendships. And I’ve always felt sad for straight men in my life that I know who maybe aren’t able to have the emotional openness to like— [John agrees.] Like, I always think about myself just like openly weeping in front of my friends, and like falling on them and like being physically affectionate. And the way that straight men aren’t allowed to do that.
john
I mean, we slept in the same bed for like two years, basically, in the beginning of our friendship.
kate
Totally. And so, something about two straight men trying to connect, but maybe there isn’t that natural chemistry there to be friends.
john
Yeah, or permission.
kate
But they just have to be—have lunch. Which, by the way, we can all—we’ve all experienced that. That goes beyond any—
john
Yeah, like having that lunch. [Kate agrees with a chuckle.] Like, clinical catchup.
kate
Yeah. The clinical catchup, which we’re obsessed with. But [chuckles]…
jesse
Define the clinical catchup, please?
john
Basically, the—
kate
Like, a joyless encounter of like two people. And maybe there’s history there. Like, you feel like you—it’s obligatory. You gotta meet up and go, “How were your last two years?” [John agrees.] But it’s medical.
john
And it’s merely—[laughs].
kate
Yeah, it’s not—[laughing] it’s not—yeah. It feels—
jesse
Like filling out one of those forms when you have a new doctor?
kate
Yeah, it just feel enforced. It feels like suddenly like the state organized this coffee. [They snort with laughter.] There is no actual joy to be pulled from it. It’s just like, “Who are you appeasing? Like your mother? The mayor?” Like it just doesn’t—why are we doing this?
john
Well, you just—it’s a good opportunity to kind of lock in your narrative.
kate
Well said.
john
That’s like the most you get out of those lunches, is you’re like—
crosstalk
Kate: You’ve got your little speech. John: “Well, I could kind of practice my little like story of my life.”
john
I’m like, “Things are good! They’re good.” And I’m—you know, and I’m—
kate
“Took me a while to get here, but—” Yeah, no, true. It’s a way to lock it in.
jesse
That was like a cowboy voice, Kate.
kate
Was it? [They confirm.] Ooh.
john
She’s [inaudible].
kate
I have a western flare, today.
john
No, but we love those boys. And I have to say, like those boys—you know, were—in the script, were a vehicle for the end of the sketch, which was the caramel as payment. And—
jesse
We should say that there is a runner through the sketch that instead of money, hot caramel is used to pay bills, which is heated on like a little portable induction heater. [They confirm.] In a little—like a little tin. Ladled.
john
So, you have—ladled onto the check—directly onto the check. But that was kind of the point of the joke for us, was that. And then we didn’t—
jesse
And why wouldn’t you build the whole thing around that? [Chuckles.]
john
Exactly. And we were like—I think that was one of the—that was like a kind of set of characters that I was maybe privately where—we talked about it, about it being kind of like, “Does this feel a little flat? Like, we’re just kind doing—"
kate
Yeah, ‘cause we’re not interested in just being like, “Straight guuuys!” Like, meeeh!
john
Yeah, making fun of straight guys. We had no desire to do that.
kate
It doesn’t feel—yeah.
john
But like, once Kate had—not to be like that actor that talks [in a weighty whisper], “When I put on the costume—"
kate
No, but it’s true. Yeah.
john
But really, when Kate had the soul patch and started doing it, I was like, “This is the most—this is like watching Robert Altman. This is like watching Short Cuts.
kate
[Laughs.] I love you.
john
I mean, I was shhhocked by what she was doing. And I also was like, “I don’t have to do anything.” Like, I felt so free. I felt so relaxed for the first time since ’82. Like, I just finally—like, when there’s like any sort of ambiguity of like, “How am I gonna do this? Like I don’t—what’s my approach? What’s my angle in, comedically?”
kate
Which so often, we never discuss. Like, that was something where we just never—
john
Literally. Did not discuss.
kate
And there was so—we had no time. We really had to just like throw the costume on, go. My hair was a crisis.
john
It was the end of the first day.
kate
Greg Lennon is a genius and was like twisting my hair manically, like the—and we just had to shoot it.
john
The sun was going down.
kate
But thank god—I think that just speaks to the trust of the friendship and the collaboration. It’s just like—it just comes, somehow. Yeah.
john
Yeah. And I just really—I’m stunned by what Kate’s doing in that sketch.
sound effect
Music swells and fades.
clip
[The muted bustle of a busy restaurant.] Kate: [Kate speaks in a lower register at a relaxed pace.] I told you we were doing like a lot of home renovation stuff. John: We’re actually doing some renovations, too. Kate: Oh, no way. John: Yeah, a buddy of mine is helping me out with some—you know that wall between the living room and the garage? Kate: Yesss. John: We had that knocked down. Kate: Oh, so the garage is exposed to the living room. John: Totally exposed. Yeah, yeah. Kate: Oooh, no way. No way. You know that wall that separates the bedroom from the bathroom? Like the main— John: Yeah. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Kate: Yeah. We knocked that down. John: Oh, amazing! Amazing. Kate: Yeah. Yeah. John: You know, my daughter’s room at the top of the stairs? Kate: Oh yeah, for sure. John: There’s that utility room next to it with the boiler, hot water heater. Kate: Uuuuh— John: But yeah, we had that wall knocked down. Kate: Okay. John: So, now the boiler’s kind of in the room with my daughter as she sleeps. Kate: Cool. No, the renovation stuff is like—you have to…
sound effect
Music swells and fades.
jesse
Does the insincerity of your schtick ever get in the way of your actual intimacy?
kate
Never.
john
No. No. We know how to drop it. Like, we—we know.
kate
Oh, and we drop it. I mean. [Chuckles.]
john
We drop it. I mean, this morning. [They laugh.] We got in the car. We were like both so depressed. [Kate agrees with a laugh.] You know. And it’s not hard for us to drop it.
jesse
Do you still have mysteries about each other?
kate
Oooh! I mean, isn’t everyone a mystery? I mean, absolutely. Yeah. [John agrees.] [Beat.] I…
jesse
E.g.?
kate
Yeah. I mean, I think people are inherently mysterious, even when you really know someone, there’s always more to uncover. Or else, I don’t know, you just—what do you do? Throw in the towel. It’s like if you get to the bottom, then…
jesse
What do you think John doesn’t know about you?
kate
A looot. [They chuckle.] I hope he finds out. That’s all I’m gonna say.
john
[Playfully.] I’m ready to find out. [Kate laughs.] [Whispering.] God, you’re gorgeous.
kate
No, John knows everything.
john
Yeah. I do feel like we kind of know everything. And what we don’t reveal is probably, on some level, felt. I mean, I would argue. I mean, I think that we I think are very sensitive to each other and kind of absorb even the subtextual. Like the stuff that doesn’t get expressed, I feel like we do express it in some way and process it and—you know what I mean?
kate
I think what you don’t know about me is ‘cause I don’t know it about myself. You—
john
And vice versa.
kate
But you also know things about me I don’t know about myself.
john
And vice versa. [They laugh.]
jesse
John, you mentioned you have a boyfriend. I don’t know if you have a partner, Kate. But what is it like for your romantic partners to have this other intense intimacy?
john
[Laughing.] That’s a really good question!
kate
I’ve been lucky that there’s always an understanding that John and I—of the sanctity of our relationship and friendship, and that we need time alone, and that there is a closeness that we have that—I mean, we’ve joked about this, but like we do have a marriage. Like, very much.
john
Yeah, there’s a kind of like—there’s a commitment involved in our friendship. [Kate agrees.] And I think there’s like a—always has been a sense of the future in our friendship. Like, there’s always been like—we’ve literally, since day one of our friendship, always had a plan for our 60th birthday. A joint 60th birthday, like at the Met.
kate
We almost went—remember, ‘cause we wanted to do a [laughs]—we just had our ten-year anniversary.
john
May 5th, yeah.
kate
And we wanted to do—we were like—well, we didn’t get to do a big ol’ party, ‘cause of covid and John’s back. But next year. Hey, look at me.
john
Next year. See you there.
kate
Year 11. [Laughs.]
john
See you there. Yeah, we wanna do a 60th, too. A 10th and a 60th. But yeah, I agree. There’s always—everyone that I’ve been romantically involved with has come—it’s come kind of after this relationship has been very publicly established. [Laughs.] [Kate agrees.] So, they’re coming in with an understanding of like the primacy. And that’s part of all these—and I think we’ve had very—
kate
It’s never been an issue, thank god.
john
It’s never been an issue. Our partners have been very respectful of the kind of—and loved it, I think, in a way too. [Kate agrees.] Yeah.
jesse
Even more with Kate Berlant and John Early still to come. When we return, we will talk about what it is like to dress as a beaver going through a TSA line. Turns out it is very uncomfortable. It’s Bullseye, from MaximumFun.org and NPR.
promo
Music: Solemn string music. Narrator: A man goes to the doctor and says that he’s depressed, and that life seems cruel. The doctor says, “Ah. The treatment is simple: the great clown, Pagliacci, is in town tonight. Go and see him and you will surely feel better.” The man bursts into tears and says, “But doctor, I am Pagliacci!” [The music swells emotionally.] “Ah, okay,” Says the doctor. “In which case, try listening to the Beef and Dairy Network Podcast.” [Air horns usher in smooth, upbeat music.] The Beef and Dairy Network Podcast is a multi-award-winning comedy podcast, and you can find it at MaximumFun.org or wherever you get your podcasts. [Music fades out.]
music
Relaxed synth with a steady beat.
jesse
It’s Bullseye. I’m Jesse Thorn. I’m talking with Kate Berlant and John Early. Let’s get back into our conversation. We talked about how intimate your relationship was from the beginning and how much your work right from the beginning had the tone of what you do now. But what’s different about your relationship now and your work now?
john
I think that if I’m looking—I mean, if you think about like from Paris to Would It Kill You to Laugh, I just think there’s a relaxing. You know. I think we’re obviously—
kate
We’ve had more experience.
john
We know when to deploy our kind of like vaudevillian like, “Honk, honk!” kind of thing that we will always like have in us and always use. You know? [Kate agrees.] But I do think—I mean, I actually think about Paris, and I think about the way that you were so relaxed to the point of falling asleep, like on camera. Like, she was in the bed—
kate
I was, I believe—I was hungover. It was the day after Thanksgiving.
john
Yeah, we were both hungover.
kate
And I was hungover and had a migraine. And so, I was on migraine medication. And I was like propping—like, in the video, I’m propping my head up a lot with my hand as I remember. [John confirms.]
jesse
We talking about a triptan here?
kate
Yeah. Truxima, honey. [John confirms.] Sumatriptan.
jesse
Knocks me out, too.
kate
I was like sooo dazed.
sound effect
Music swells and fades.
clip
Kate (Paris): Do you miss it, um, more now or—ugh. I mean, stupid question. [Chuckles.] John: Ask it again. Try it again. Kate: Do you miss Paris? John: Yesss! Kate: Thank god you’re coming over, because we can talk about this. Because I can’t talk about it with other friends. John: I can’t talk about it with other friends! Kate: People are scared. John: People here are scared! It’s a fear-based culture! In Paris, it’s a luxury-based culture. Kate: It’s a fear-based culture in America.
sound effect
Music swells and fades.
john
But you’ve always been capable of like—I think you’ve always been capable of kind of just getting in a flow state, performance-wise. And I’m a little—I mean, this is why I have back problems, is I’m a little more like [nasally] rigid and loud. And like—and so, I would say like I think both of us just like kind of trust it more. I mean, we’ve always trusted it, but there’s just—something is—something’s a little more— Like, to me, when I watch this special, something feels like less forced, maybe.
kate
Yeah, yeah. It’s a little more relaxed.
john
Yeah. Well, when I watch the whole thing, I feel like there is like a kind of like soft kind of conversational, kind of like languid, dreamy quality to it.
kate
Yeah. Great.
john
That’s nice. Yeah. [Chuckles.]
jesse
There’s a sketch in the show where the two of you are parents with a kid in an airport. And you’re beavers. [Kate giggles and confirms.] It’s a regular people airport, but you’re human beavers.
sound effect
Music swells and fades.
clip
[As the beaver family speaks, you can hear them struggle to speak around their prosthetic teeth.] John: Put this in the check back, and we would’ve gotten a fee! An exorbitant fee. You know what? I’m just gonna hang on to it, read it on the plane. It’ll be fine. Kate: You are not gonna read that thing. John: Yes, I am gonna read it! Kate: This line is not moving. We are at a standstill. John: Oh god. Kate: I just hope I get on the plane. John: Well, I also—[mumbles]. Kate: They’re boarding. They’re boarding. Frankie: What’s up, folks? How would you like to breeze through this security line today, huh? Kate: What does that mean? John: Who are you? Frankie: My name’s Frankie. I’m with Breezer. John: Breezer? What is that? What is Breezer? Frankie: That’s a VIP experience at the airport. Could have you at your gate within five minutes, huh? Kate: Five minutes?! Frankie: Oh damn, boy! You’re strong. [Chuckles.] Congratulations. Kate: Ask how much. Ask how much. John: [Mumbling.] Uh, how much is it? Frankie: You don’t need to worry about that!
sound effect
Music swells and fades.
jesse
Are you meant to look like—from The Lion, the Witch, and—the live action Lion, The Witch, and The Wardrobe? Is that what’s supposed to be happening there? Not the movie. The like BBC television movie?
john
Right, no, of course. I love that one.
jesse
‘Cause it has the same deeply distressing quality. [Laughs.]
kate
Yeah, yeah. We’re just trying to be beavers.
john
We were just trying to be beavers. Like, we each wanted to be like a—we wanted to really have prosthetics that were like as real as possible. But I think that, if you’re feeling that, it’s because that was a time when people were using prosthetics in a way that was like more like sincere and practical and less about—there wasn’t like the CGI blend of certain elements. [Kate agrees.] And like, so—and that was—like, we like in our like little deck for this—for the beaver sketch—we had The Coneheads in there. Like the family picture of The Coneheads. Like, it’s that same kind of just like… I don’t know.
kate
It’s not—the attempt isn’t so much to become so real that—I mean, like I think the beaver makeup is amazing. And like—
john
Yeah. But if we wanted—or if we had the money to, someone might have wanted to sweeten it with CGI.
kate
And somehow, then it becomes something else. [John agrees.] And it’s like no longer… what is that? It’s—it’s something profound about—just something in there—
jesse
It becomes uncanny? [John agrees.]
kate
Yeah, it’s like the uncanny valley or whatever. Or it’s just like—it doesn’t—the attempt isn’t to… there’s something about knowing that John and I are actually in there and that being clear is why it’s funny. [John agrees.] If we just disappear into full beavers, it’d be like—yeah, then they’re beavers. And it doesn’t—it like loses something.
john
Yeah, like hearing us struggle with the teeth. You know, I think is—
kate
Yeah, like we’re in a mask. We’re in the prosthetics.
jesse
The teeth have a little bit of gross color. [They agree.] It has a little bit of Brecht to it. There’s a little bit of sort of confrontational quality that makes you step outside and makes the— [John makes chomping noises.] —content feel a little—
john
What’s that word?
jesse
More intense. Let’s call it the V-Effect (VFX), shall we? [They agree.] Well, Kate and John, I’m so grateful to you for coming and being on the show. Your special and your other work is so funny. [They thank him.] And I so admire it. So, thank you for coming here and doing this.
crosstalk
John: Thank you for watching it. [Giggles.] Kate: Thank you for watching it and liking it, truly.
john
Didn’t we—like, we haven’t—
kate
Thanks for having us.
john
You know. We—no one’s watched it yet. [Kate affirms.]
jesse
Kate Berlant and John Early. Their special is called Would It Kill You to Laugh. It is extraordinarily funny. You can stream it starting this week, on Peacock.
music
Buzzy synth with a steady beat.
jesse
That’s the end of another episode of Bullseye. Bullseye is created from the homes me and the staff of Maximum Fun, in and around greater Los Angeles, California. Here at my house, I’ve been unboxing my late aunt’s record collection. I inherited them from her, and they were shipped to me by Amtrak from Washington D.C., where she lived. Here’s one that I recommend pretty unequivocally: it's the self-titled debut album by Merry Clayton. M-E-R-R-Y, Merry Clayton. Incredible, slightly rock-tinged soul album from the early 1970s. Listen to it on your streaming service! The show is produced by speaking into microphones. Our senior producer is Kevin Ferguson. Our producers are Jesus Ambrosio and Richard Robey. Our production fellow at Maximum Fun is Tabatha Myers. We get booking help from Mara Davis. Our interstitial music is by Dan Wally, also known as DJW. Our theme music is by The Go! Team. It’s called “Huddle Formation”. Our thanks to The Go! Team for sharing it with us, along with their label, Memphis Industries. Bullseye is on YouTube, Twitter, and Facebook. So, connect with us in those places. We share all our interviews in all of those. And I think that’s about it. Just remember: all great radio hosts have a signature signoff.
promo
Speaker: Bullseye with Jesse Thorn is a production of MaximumFun.org and is distributed by NPR. [Music fades out.]
About the show
Bullseye is a celebration of the best of arts and culture in public radio form. Host Jesse Thorn sifts the wheat from the chaff to bring you in-depth interviews with the most revered and revolutionary minds in our culture.
Bullseye has been featured in Time, The New York Times, GQ and McSweeney’s, which called it “the kind of show people listen to in a more perfect world.” Since April 2013, the show has been distributed by NPR.
If you would like to pitch a guest for Bullseye, please CLICK HERE. You can also follow Bullseye on Twitter, YouTube, and Facebook. For more about Bullseye and to see a list of stations that carry it, please click here.
Get in touch with the show
@bullseye.bsky.social
@bullseyewithjessethornPeople
How to listen
Stream or download episodes directly from our website, or listen via your favorite podcatcher!
